Showing posts with label beatless. Show all posts
Showing posts with label beatless. Show all posts

Beatless Episode 3 Review

 

   If you paid attention to my previous reviews of its episodes, you will know that I don't think very highly of Beatless- this episode has been barely different, but that barely here stands for a couple of inches towards the positive direction.
  This episode's hook is the kidnapping of Lacia, which the episode uses to show how hIE are perceived as nothing more than objects- stuff we already know. This pretty much continues into a long, long car "chase." And please keep in mind that we are using the word chase very loosely- it happens at usual car cruising speed. So, if 60 km/h down the suburbs gets your veins filled with adrenaline, you should stop reading and watch this episode right now!
  Pretty much after that, we get introduced to the kidnapper for a brief moment, resulting in him being portrayed as a stereotypical psycho before Kouka shows up for a brief action scene, and- the credits roll. This progression of the plot leaves a lot to be desired- in the pacing especially; show seems to be moving at a much slower pace than it is supposed to- here we do get some information about a particular group of hIEs know as "Red Boxes," which I found to be somewhat interesting, but not very well explained. This seems to be a recurring problem in this show- it expects you just to pick up these concepts as the plot moves along, without any explanations. This is because, primarily, all characters are residents of this world and pretty much know all of this fancy terminology. It would be much better if it had a character who was a foreigner to this world so that we would get better explanations.
  Why was this episode slightly better than the previous one? Well, it introduces the intrigue behind the character of Kouka and Lacia and brings forwards some themes related to robots which are mildly interesting, but again- I hope that the show does not delay these revelations for too long. I just hope this does not go in the same way regarding the mysteries as .hack did...
  Visually, this episode is so-so, the slight highlight being the action scene at the end- it feels rough around the edges and overall unappealing while in motion.



Score breakdown:

Story: C
Has some potentially interesting themes, some intrigue behind Lacia and Kouka.

Characters: C
The new character, the kidnapper, is stereotypical, but there is some intrigue to be found in Kouka and Lacia.

Animation: C
Has a so-so action sequence at the end, overall unappealing in motion. CG cars are not jarring as they seemed at first.

Art: A
Nothing to say here which was not stated before.

+ Some intrigue

- Slow pacing for an action series, needs to hurry up with its revelations to keep the viewers engaged.

Beatless Episode 2 Review

   

     Immediately from the first shot of this episode, I realized the core problem of this series' first two episodes- it seems like the crew behind it don't know what to do with it. The second episode, plot-wise seems like a filler episode from a series that has a couple dozens of episodes. Basically, it is sort-of a side story about Lacia being used as a fashion model. That's it- zero plot-twists, if you do not count the scene after the credits roll, no one receives any character development, but we do get some world-building regarding hIE, and how they function in the society in the relation with humans. The obvious stuff, you know- discrimination against them and the fact that they are perceived more as objects rather than human beings. The execution of these elements is mediocre and stereotypical, and worst of all- obvious. When they started talking about hIE, I immediately knew what I was going to get by the end of that conversation. New characters that we get to meet are, again- nothing even remotely interesting.
     At the end, we get a post-credits scene with a guy in the room who receives a "visit" from Kouka, a red-haired hIE from the poorly animated scene from the first episode. This feels pointless at the end because the entire episode is wasted on useless conversations and that fashion show which does nothing for the plot, except wasting time. There the show introduces a poorly explained concept called "Analog hack," which seems somewhat promising, but I can't see it going anywhere.
     Visually, this episode is even bigger meh that the first one- we get zero action this time, so that is to be expected. What hurts the animation the most is the poor composition of the shots, which often seems embarrassing- at the beginning there is this reality-bending embarrassing shot of Arato's face, with black space around them- I have no idea what they were trying this to symbolize. The design of the world is very good, mixing familiarity with science fiction to achieve quite a bit of a result.
    If you haven't already started watching Beatless, I cannot entice you to start watching it, to be perfectly honest. There is a potential for an interesting story, but the execution of this episode feels mediocre.

Score breakdown:

Story: D+
Feels like a filler episode from a long-running series.

Characters: D-
No attempts at character development, new characters are not interesting.

Animation: C-
No action this time, nothing worthy of praise.

Art: A
redjuice's character designs are great, the world is well designed.

+ Has potential to be something great, good character and world design.

- The poor composition of certain shots, the animation is nothing to get excited about, same can be said for the story.

Beatless Episode 1 Review


     In short- Guilty Crown 1.5

    The traffic light switches. A character walks across the street. The traffic light switches. A character walks across the street. Now, if this sounds monotonous to you, because it is, you will be surprised that this is the composition of one of the first shots of Beatless’ first episode, which is true to its name- beatless.
     Moments in, I was overcome by the feeling of deja vu, and with a good reason- this show does indeed feel like Guilty Crown, and I am not just talking about the fact that both shows share the same character designer, but rather the overall premise and characters- Arato and Shuu are basically the same character (visually and personality wise), and the same can be said for Lacia, which is basically this show’s mascot and the clone of Inori. It doesn’t help that the show starts in the most non-unique place ever- high school, giving us a taste of school life, which by this point in anime feels like rotten spam, before introducing us to a couple of generic guys in a helicopter fighting other “hIE,” which are supposed to be robots who function as slaves for humans?
    The world building is for this episode barely there, and what I found to be the most memorable is how the convenience store functions, which should serve as a sign of how uninteresting this world feels. This is not to say that it does not have potential to explore themes of relationships of humans and machines, which has been done before and more effectively.
    Show’s art style is solid overall- redjuice again proves to the world that he is the God of female character designs, which look sleek, attractive and poster-worthy. Same cannot be said for the boys, which look rather meh. But, those designs look only good when they are not moving, because of the animation here, during action sequences especially, looks janky and rough. 3D CG animation, which this episode uses for the cars, is jarring as well, but it is fairly brief.

    Overall, Beatless does not make a good impression in its first episode. It is not to say that it lacks potential, but its stereotypical delivery, underwhelming production values, and copy-paste characters make this questionable. I would sum this up as poor man’s Guilty Crown.

Score breakdown:

Story: C-

Does not make a great impression, despite the potential for some interesting philosophy.

Characters: D

Copy-pasted directly from Guilty Crown, which is a show you do not want to copy characters from.

Animation: C-

Action sequences lack fluidity and are overall very basic.

Art: B+

redjuice’s female character designs shine, but the boys not so much. The world feels a-ok.


+ Great female character designs, has the potential for some philosophical themes regarding robots.

- Feels like Guilty Crown clone, intentionally or not- its characters are stereotypical at best, underwhelming animation.